Connect with us

Miami Dolphins

Dolphins Trade QB Ryan Tannehill – Where Things Went Wrong in Miami

Travis Wingfield

Published

on

Why the Dolphins’ First, Round-One QB in 29 Years Ultimately Failed

UPDATE – Ryan Tannehill has been traded to the Tennessee Titans. He has agreed to a one-year contract with Tennessee to backup another disappointing first-round Quarterback in Marcus Mariotta. Miami sends its sixth-round (pick 188) pick along with Tannehill to Tennessee in exchange for the Titans  2020 fourth-round pick and a 2019 seventh-round pick (pick 235).

Ryan Tannehill has an extremely strong arm and throws a tight spiral. He can make every NFL throw and his outstanding athleticism translates well to the football field”

The physical traits were unanimously marveled at by scouts and pundits alike back in the 2012 NFL Draft. With elite velocity on the most difficult throws, and athleticism to burn the defense with his legs, it was never an issue of physical shortcomings for Ryan Tannehill.

So why didn’t it work out in Miami? Why did it take the Dolphins seven years to make a decision on the former eighth overall pick in 2012? Why were the flashes of brilliance met by maddening moments of head-scratching valleys?

“You’re going to get everyone fired.”

That was a direct quote pulled from a heated exchange between former Dolphins Offensive Coordinator Bill Lazor and Tannehill from the 2015 season. It was later revealed that Lazor often put together his game plans without the input of his starting quarterback – a rather mind-boggling approach in a league driven by preparation.

In hindsight, seven years in, Lazor was right. Tannehill lasted the better part of a decade in Miami. He survived four play-callers, two head coaches, and three general managers.

Turn on any Dolphins game from those seven years and its more-likely-than-not that the broadcaster will remind the viewer that Tannehill was a receiver-turned-quarterback at Texas A&M.

Of course, Tannehill was always a quarterback. He was recruited to play quarterback, he practiced as a quarterback, and participated in the quarterback meetings. Rather than sit on the bench as a freshman and sophomore, Tannehill decided to contribute as a wide out at College Station.

But you wouldn’t know about his time spent as a quarterback from his playing style. Tannehill often missed reads, misidentified robbers or disguises in coverage, and was regularly guilty of the back-breaking mistake. Any time Tannehill faced a Rex Ryan Buffalo Bills defense, or the Baltimore Ravens under Dean Peas, it resulted in a loss and multiple turnovers by the quarterback (coaches known for disguised coverage and intense pressure packages).

Tannehill’s off-field exploits as a biology major in college, and aspiring orthopedic surgeon post-playing career, convinced the Phins’ faithful that he was an astute quarterback between the ears.

Studying, however, only shows a discipline for the job – it’s not an indicator that the player can apply the practical knowledge in a game-situation. It’s one thing to know how the play is designed and what the coverage is supposed to do against that design, but it’s entirely another to process new information in the heat of the moment.

Even in year-seven, Tannehill struggled with this aspect of the game.

Detractors will point back to the embarrassing moment on HBO’s Hard Knocks when Tannehill wasn’t aware of the divisional alignment.

It’s unfair to derive, from this video, that Tannehill would never be able to put things together from a processing standpoint. Though it is evident that he’s measured in his approach. Like a lot of the book-smart population, Tannehill takes a beat longer to process what he’s learned and how to quickly apply it to the situation at hand. The lack of feel, or a lack of natural instincts to play the position, can slow reactions by a half-second – an eternity in the world of football.

A better snapshot of Tannehill’s poor decision making in the line-of-fire, a clip from the same episode of Hard Knocks. Wearing his red quarterback practice jersey, Tannehill takes off on a broken play and lunges for a first down.

Not only is Tannehill unaware of how massively ignorant that decision was in the moment, he doesn’t process the advice of veteran Quarterback David Garrard after the fact.

Those clips, on their own, are anecdotal at best. Fortunately, hindsight gives us seven years of applicable examples.

An example of a less-than-ideal locker room presence was offered on social media Thursday. A peak behind the curtain regarding Tannehill’s unpopularity among former Dolphin teammates was issued by. fellow 2012 classmate, Olivier Vernon. Vernon’s defense of Robert Quinn left Tannehill in the wake and provided the bat signal for Mike Wallace and Sean Smith to disparage the soon-to-be former Dolphins Quarterback.

We already covered Bill Lazor’s less-than-impressed sentiment towards the leader of his 2014 and 2015 offense.

It was widely known that Tannehill’s best, most translatable trait at an early age was his ability to throw from outside the pocket. Still, Joe Philbin and Mike Sherman prohibited Tannehill from playing outside the framework and structure of the offense.

Tannehill was accurate on 81% of his throws outside the pocket vs. 70% on cumulative throws during his rookie season. Still, Sherman called plays that rolled Tanenhill outside, by design, less than 6% of the time. That number, miraculously, decreased in year-two prior to Sherman’s dismissal.

Fast-forward to 2016 when Adam Gase brought his complex version of the Earhardt & Perkins scheme (previously perfected by Peyton Manning) to Miami. The Dolphins stumbled to a 1-4 start and the offense sputtered in back-to-back low-scoring performances against the Bengals and Titans respectively.

Then, in week six against the Pittsburgh Steelers, Gase adapted his offense to a 12-personnel-heavy, play-action attack. Tannehill and the offense took off under back-to-back 200-yard rushing performances by Jay Ajayi.

Miami would win seven of the next eight games and Tannehill’s passer rating eclipsed triple digits in those eight games (the second such stretch of his career (2014)).

But that’s when things reverted back to old ways. Tannehill, at his absolute professional peak, took a shot to the knee by Cardinals Defensive Tackle Calais Campbell. As a result, Tannehill would miss the next 20 games (including Miami’s playoff game that season) and return more than 630 days later.

The first video in this column comes from that game. Gase, who insisted to ESPN’s Jeff Darlington, that [Gase] “had Tannehill exactly where [Gase] wanted him – [Tannehill] is going to have a monster year,” tried once more to get his quarterback up-to-speed in the tempo, shotgun-based attack.

Miami’s offense was good enough in the first three games of the year, but bottomed out entirely the following two games in New England and Cincinnati. Tannehill would miss the next five games before returning with a shoulder held together by Scotch Tape.

Behind Tannehill, the Dolphins offense ranked near the bottom of the league in all major offensive categories including third down percentage and yards-per-game.

Pre-injury, at his best, Tannehill was a highly gifted quarterback that oozed upside. Before Tannehill arrived, Miami was a hotbed of lousy quarterback play. With a new opening day starter just about every year post-Marino, Tannehill provided Miami something they did not reciprocate – stability. Perhaps things could’ve been different if the Dolphins offered a semblance of said-stability, or if the team ever managed to put together an offensive line better than bottom-tier.

Even as Tannehill’s biggest proponent, and perpetuator of his 2016 season providing a sign of change, it’s time to admit that the former Aggie was ultimately a failure as a Dolphin.

Today, that is undeniable. Onto the next.

@WingfieldNFL

Advertisement
5 Comments

5 Comments

  1. Chip

    March 14, 2019 at 6:27 pm

    Good read. But emphasis wrong. RT needed to develop. In the rt situation would be a Kirk Cousins mid level QB. Please add up # of Head coaches, OC’s, new offenses he has had as a developing QB. Then give some stats on iTunes he has has played behind. The Dolphins Organization failed at developing and protecting a possible long term QB. Probably best for RT to get out of this dumpster fire and start fresh.

    • Mike

      March 16, 2019 at 10:01 am

      Agreed with Chip and others. I know this is a Phins friendly site, but RT never had the level of protection that would be acceptable even for a college program. It’s too bad he didn’t get traded long before now so that he would have a chance to shine. The knee injury that appears to have been handled poorly by the team’s medical staff took 18 months aways from his career.
      Congrats to Ryan and Lauren for getting out of South Florida.

  2. Shane

    March 14, 2019 at 7:08 pm

    Coach Lazor didn’t include him in the prep? That was a failure of the coach. Not the player. I’m glad you were able to include one sentence on the miserable offensive line play too. We got rid of Richie Incognito in the middle of all of this. Look at the play when his knee got torn up. Look at the play this year when his arm got hurt. He’s a solid QB just had very little food around him. As if Mike Wallace’s opinion matters!!

  3. Pferra

    March 14, 2019 at 11:10 pm

    What has Mike Wallace done since he left Pittsburgh , and O V is going to take up for the defensive player and not that OV has done a whole lot after he left Miami so maybe they were system players also

  4. CC

    March 17, 2019 at 9:40 am

    I enjoyed the article and the simple fact is Ryan can’t read the defense fast enough. If it’s his first read he looks good, but that is it. Other quarterbacks look good without great offensive lines and ours has been terrible.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Miami Dolphins

Miami Dolphins Sign Chris Reed

Jason Hrina

Published

on

Image Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports

Looks like the Miami Dolphins have begun replacing the plethora of offensive linemen they either released or let walk this past offseason.

According to the Dolphins official social media account, the team signed offensive guard Chris Reed.

Details of the contract are currently unknown, but with the losses of Ja’Wuan James, Ted Larsen, Josh Sitton and possibly even players like Jake Brendel and Travis Swanson, the Dolphins need bodies to fill out their roster.

After signing with the Jacksonville Jaguars as an undrafted free agent out of the 2015 NFL draft, Reed was placed on the team’s practice squad and wasn’t activated until September, 2016. Over the past three seasons, Reed has been active for 25 games and started 8 of them.

You can’t expect too much from this signing, as Reed is simply expected to compete for depth on the offensive line and it’s possible he doesn’t even make the team out of training camp. Then again, Ted Larsen was originally supposed to be offensive line depth and he ended up playing 1,272 snaps over the course of his two-year Dolphins career.

Continue Reading

Miami Dolphins

Rebuilding Previous Rebuilds

Jason Hrina

Published

on

Image Credit: Steve Mitchell-USA TODAY Sports

Now that we have accepted the notion that the Miami Dolphins are going to start rebuilding their franchise in 2019 (and as a result, a lot of losing will incur), we have moved on to the optimistic hope that this team is going to build their foundation “right”.

Hope is about the only thing that will temper the frustration that comes with going 6-10 with freshly signed Ryan Fitzpatrick as our starting quarterback, so over the next calendar year, you’re going to hear how most decisions are geared towards 2020.

Sure, Fitzpatrick will dazzle us with a couple 400-yard passing games and a few offensive performances that trick us into believing that we don’t need to desperately grab a franchise quarterback, but don’t let those extremely inconsistent anomalies fool you. Miami most definitely needs a franchise quarterback – one that leaves us with minimal doubts at the top of the draft.

Are they going to trade up for one in 2019? Or are they going to, um, conveniently lose in 2019 and attempt to save their assets for 2020, where there’s a chance that four starting-caliber quarterbacks come out of college – all of whom are possibly better than the top-2 quarterbacks in this class: Dwayne Haskins and Kyler Murray?

As Travis echoed on Sunday, the Miami Dolphins are building a treasure trove of draft picks that will allow themselves to navigate the murkiest of trade waters in either 2019 or 2020. With the trade of Ryan Tannehill to the Tennessee Titans netting Miami an extra 4th-round draft pick – along with the assumption that losing Ja’Wuan James to the Denver Broncos will return an extra 3rd-round pick as a compensatory selection – Miami will have the ability to tack on whichever mid-round picks are required to seal the deal for a top-3 draft pick.

But with all of these assets in mind, can we confidently assume that the Dolphins are just one year away from being a relevant franchise that can sustain success? No, not one bit.

Since Chris Grier took over as the Director of College Scouting in 2007, Miami has had 5 drafts in which they have had at least 9 draft picks to work with. Although it’s obvious that not every draft pick is going to pan out, the assumption is that a team should be able to identify enough cheap labor to fill their roster. You don’t need superstars in every round, though it would be nice if the Dolphins drafted even one of them.

Before you get ready to soak in the success of 2020, I’m going to remind you of the somber past we have together. Hopefully, Grier doesn’t allow history to repeat itself:

2007

Chris Grier’s first year on the job yielded Miami with multiple draft steals, but came with an ample amount of draft busts as well.

Whether the selection was general manager Randy Mueller‘s, head coach Cam Cameron‘s, Grier’s, or a combination of the three, the Miami Dolphins shocked everyone by selecting Ted Ginn Jr with the 9th-overall pick in the draft.

Choosing Ted Ginn Jr over Brady Quinn proved to be the correct choice, but was Ginn really the player you wanted to commit a top-10 pick to? Especially when he was coming off of an injury and was seen more as a dynamic kick returner than an elite, #1 receiver?

Here are a few players taken shortly after Ginn was picked #9: Patrick Willis (11), Marshawn Lynch (12) and Darrelle Revis (14). I was going to include Lawrence Timmons (15th-overall), but I don’t think Miami fans are going to think too fondly of that linebacker (though let’s be honest, he was still a better pick than Ginn).

But the Miami Dolphins had 10 draft picks in 2007, and should have been able to build a team with more than just a failed 1st-round pick, right? Alas, this is what they graced us with that year:

Paul Soliai in the 4th-round and Brandon Fields in the 7th-round ended up being phenomenal choices for the Dolphins, as both players combined to play 227 games with Miami. Even Samson Satele was a good selection in the 2nd-round; Miami just doesn’t understand their own talent and allowed Satele to be a good starting center for two other teams instead of their own.

The rest of that draft class? Combined to be active for 32 games with the Dolphins. All of which were off the team by the start of the 2008 season.

2008

Coming off of a 1-15 season that felt less like a rebuild and more like a purgatory, the Dolphins were now poised to genuinely begin their ascension with the 1st-overall selection in the draft.

The thing is, Miami’s biggest mistake wasn’t selecting Jake Long with the #1 overall pick, but bringing an archaic Bill Parcells on board to build a team for the future.

Parcells figured there was no sense having a franchise quarterback if there was no one to protect him (the opposite logic of what the Dolphins did with Ryan Tannehill throughout his career), and selected Jake Long to protect whoever’s blindside.

You might be able to excuse Parcells for selecting a potential hall of fame left tackle (for the first four years of their career) over Matt Ryan, since Miami did have 8 more draft picks that year. Instead, this is how the draft shook out:

Kendall Langford was a solid player on the Dolphins defensive line throughout his rookie contract, but other than Jake Long he was the only player to plug a hole on the roster. You can say Chad Henne played prominently for the Dolphins, but we all know he was a detriment more than a solution, and even forced Miami to pick yet another quarterback in the 2nd-round the following draft.

Phillip Merling gave us that exciting interception against Brett Favre and the New York Jets the year Chad Pennington led the team to the playoffs, but other than that, he was basically an extra 1st-round pick that ended up being a complete bust.

After two years and 19 draft picks, the Dolphins should have set themselves up to be a young team worth reckoning with. Looking back, there were really only 5 players that filled a capable roster spot: Satele, Soliai, Fields, Long and Langford. For reference, NFL rosters held 52 players…

2009

After two failed drafts and nearly 19 wasted draft picks, the Miami Dolphins actually got a draft right. This comes with the caveat that it’s the third-consecutive year in which the team is selecting a quarterback in the 2nd-round, so it tells you just how lost the Dolphins really are.

Pat White was a fascinating college athlete to watch, but he had no business being a quarterback in the NFL. The football community was stunned to see White selected so high, but the Dolphins envisioned a quarterback that could complete their wildcat offense and keep opposing defenses confused at all times.

The only confusion White caused was on Miami’s offense, because the playbook was extremely small for the limited quarterback, and the offense was stale at best.

Miami’s best selections came from Vontae Davis and Sean Smith. The team also envisioned having a pair of young, cheap, shutdown corners to give Tom Brady, Brett Favre and whoever the Buffalo Bills had hell. And they were really onto something for a little bit, but Joe Philbin‘s inability to handle egos mixed with some immaturity on the player’s side “forced” the Dolphins to trade Davis and allow Smith to leave in free agency.

At the time, this was a very good draft, but looking back at it, it’s just some more disappointment:

Brian Hartline received a contract extension with the team and probably outperformed all of our expectations. Maybe it speaks to the lack of playmakers the Dolphins have had over their history, but Hartline has the 7th most receiving yards and 9th most receptions in Dolphins history. We can knock the extension as a separate topic, but selecting Hartline in the 4th-round was a very good draft pick.

Chris Clemons ended up playing 80 games with the Dolphins and served as a valuable depth player for 5 seasons.

This can be deemed a good draft for the Dolphins, but the problem is, we’re excited the team was able to find 3 starters. While every team would love to say they found 3 starters in each draft, the Dolphins didn’t have much of a roster around those guys, which meant the team hadn’t rebuilt much of anything up to this point.

A budding franchise looking to sustain success is going to need more than a good #3 receiver to escape mediocrity.

2012

2012 was another very good draft for the Dolphins that saw virtually no sustained success going forward. This is the point where you have to wonder if the Miami Dolphins legitimately try to win or if they’re fine creating media headlines and bringing in ad revenue.

Ryan Tannehill was the first 1st-round quarterback the Dolphins selected since Dan Marino back in 1983. Between all of the excitement and optimism, fans were sold on the fact that Tannehill was going to turn the team around (after he firmly learned the quarterback position). His old coach at Texas A&M, Mike Sherman, was set to be his offensive coordinator, so you know Miami was really building this thing right because, you know, “chemistry”.

7 seasons later, and there are no surviving members of the 2012 draft class. In fact, only one of them made it past year 4 (Tannehill) – which also happens to be the same number of players eventually arrested from this draft class (Jonathan Martin).

How can a team sustain success when the team doesn’t sustain any of their successful players?

Olivier Vernon and Lamar Miller proved to be great risks that Jeff Ireland took. Coming right out of the Dolphins backyard from the University of Miami, Vernon and Miller were underclassmen that Ireland saw potential in. And he was right.

Both outperformed their draft status and earned themselves wealthy contracts in free agency. This goes back to the argument that the Dolphins are incompetent when it comes to signing their own draft picks, so overall, this draft doesn’t seem like much, but this draft could have been much more than a free agent payday for 3 of their selections.

Rishard Matthews was one of the best 7th-round picks in Dolphins history, but Philbin’s deadpan personality placed Matthews on the bench for most of his rookie contract rather than the starting lineup ahead of players like B.J. Cunningham and Legedu Naanee.

As of 2019, the Dolphins are still looking for a player at every position from the list of 2012 draft picks (QB, RT, DE, TE, LB, WR and DT). You can say Miami doesn’t need a running back, but that’s also the easiest position to find and it’s not even like the team currently has a solidified running back room anyway.

2013

Identifying a “can’t-miss” athlete in an inactive market, Jeff Ireland made one of the best draft-day trades of the century and traded the team’s 1st-round pick (12th-overall) and 2nd-round pick (42nd-overall) to move up to #3 overall. That kind of trade would be unheard of today, where those top picks are commodities that you have to pry away with current and future draft capital.

So what did the Dolphins do with their robbery? Select a stellar athlete with a history of demons that rivals that of Josh Gordon.

Dion Jordan was built to be a football player, but he never actually wanted to be a football player. He wanted to escape reality and realized this was a profession he was good at. Fortunately for Jordan, but unfortunately for the Dolphins, Jordan took 5 years to mature past all of those inner turmoils and emerge as a defensive threat.

But like the theme of this article, his success doesn’t benefit the Miami Dolphins one bit.

Dion Jordan wasn’t the only player to fail Miami’s expectations yet perform better elsewhere.

2nd-round pick Jamar Taylor was always hampered by injuries and was shipped to the Cleveland Browns for a 27 slot draft boost in the 7th-round (a farcry from #54 overall). Dion Sims was a solid backup and blocking tight end before cashing in with the Chicago Bears. Mike Gillislee was a decent kick returner who has seen a good amount of success as a running back with the Buffalo Bills and New England Patriots. Even Caleb Sturgis was viewed as a “bust” and has since played 36 games for other teams.

You could argue that Don Jones was Miami’s best draft pick behind Dion Sims that year, and that’s only because he was a very good gunner on special teams.

Truth is, the Dolphins have had plenty of opportunities to rebuild and yet, years later, here we are, still trying to rebuild. So now that Chris Grier has ultimate control, will this be the rebuild the Dolphins finally turn it around? 6th time’s a charm, right?

Continue Reading

Miami Dolphins

Free Agent Analysis: Quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick

Travis Wingfield

Published

on

Buckle up, Phins Fans – the Fitzmagic Roller Coaster is coming to your town

Ryan Fitzpatrick is on his eight NFL team following a circuitous route that spans 14 seasons as a professional football player. The journeyman stopgap heads to America’s retirement home on a two-year contract that starts at $11 million and could escalate to $20 million if unspecified incentives are met.

Though details of the contract’s structure are not yet available, it’s a near certainty that the bulk of the money will be paid out in year-one. With the Dolphins eating a chunk of dead cap, and pushing assets down the road, this move not only helps Miami get closer to the salary floor, it secures a sturdy backup quarterback for the 2020 season.

Whether it’s Kyler Murray, Dwayne Haskins, Tua Tagovailoa, Jake Fromm or any other quarterback prospect, Fitzpatrick has been heralded for his calm demeanor and approach to providing this very important element to his past teams.

Barring a trade-up for one of the top two prospects in this draft Fitzpatrick will be under-center when the Dolphins open the season on the second Sunday in September. Only one September ago, Fitzpatrick was on an unprecedented roll for a quarterback of his caliber – of any caliber, really.

After the three-game stretch of consecutive 400 yard outputs, Fitzpatrick throttled into a nosedive throwing for less than 250 yards in four of his next five starts. Cumulatively, his passer rating on the season was 100.4, but he failed to eclipse the 90.0 mark in all but one of his final six starts.

The strengths and weaknesses of Fitzpatrick’s game are abundantly clear. Where the flashes with Ryan Tannehill provided false hope, Fitzpatrick is an open book – it only takes a couple of games of all-22 to figure out exactly who he is.

First, the strengths. I’ve talked at length about the importance of a backup quarterback providing the locker room and huddle with a sense of comradery. Whether it’s this season or next, Fitzpatrick will eventually be relegated to the number-two QB. The Ewing Theory suggests that the rest of the roster can elevate its game when the backup enters the lineup, but that typically only applies when said backup is likable.

That clip also showcases the gamer-mentality of Fitzpatrick. With reckless abandon, he’ll take a hit for his team in a way you’d never want your franchise quarterback to play.

As for Fitzpatrick the starter, the strength of his game is also his biggest weakness. He trusts his eyes as much as any quarterback going right now and will let ‘er rip without hesitation. There’s a hint of Matt Moore in his game where he evaluates pre-snap and makes quick decisions based on the leverage of the defense.

The first touchdown of the season for Tampa Bay provides a terrific example of Fitzpatrick’s ability to move the defense with his eyes and hips. The clip also showcases his strength as a play-action passer when given a comfortable pocket.

There’s a reason he’s been on eight teams in 14 years, however. That anticipation, coupled with sloppy mechanics, gets him into a lot of hot water. If the defense is at all nuanced, and capable of disguising coverage, he’s going to turn the ball over a heck of a lot.

Randomly, the ball will sail as he is prone to rushing his setup and spraying bullets all over the field. Pressure in his face only amplifies this shortcoming.

All things told, this was the best veteran option available both in terms of playing time and veteran mentor to the inevitable draft pick coming in a year or two. There will be equal parts excitement and sheer frustration with Fitzpatrick playing in Miami.

As far as the Tank for Tua conversation, this signing likely solidifies that Miami will not be the worst team in football. I’ve argued that they would never reach those valleys to begin, even with a rookie or Luke Falk under-center. I believe too strongly in Brian Flores and the staff he has assembled for this team to lose a number of games in the teens. Fitzpatrick at least gets Miami out of the massive hole of unworthy NFL quarterback territory.

Ideally, the Dolphins find their quarterback straight away and never have to start Fitzpatrick. The more likely outcome is that he starts the season and puts the Dolphins in a tough spot regarding the playing time incentives in his contract.

This signing is great from a financial standpoint right now, but if the Harvard product (had to get it in) starts hitting those contract escalators, that would not be ideal.

@WingfieldNFL

Continue Reading
Advertisement

LATEST

Advertisement
Advertisement

Trending